Traditional vs Modern Medicines
Overview
Traditional vs Modern Medicines What will fight off the most bacteria, traditional or modern medicines. I used 3 traditional medicines and one modern medicine. I swabbed bacteria from my hockey gloves onto petri dishes that had the medicines on it. I waited 3 days for my bacteria to grow and once they grew I counted the bacteria to see what fought off the most bacteria. After counting I found that the modern medicine used killed off the most bacteria. It helps to show that our traditional teachings are still valuable even if our modern medicines fight off the most bacteria.
Video
This video could not be played here. Watch it on the original project page.
Why?
Traditional Vs Modern medicines, which will fight off bacteria growth better. The purpose of this project is to determine whether traditional medicines or modern day medicine would be best to prevent the growth of bacteria. Elders used these traditional medicines to fight sickness and this shows the effectiveness compared to modern day medicines. Though I have no doubt that the traditional medicines work and have worked in the past to fight off infection. I believe that modern day medicines will work a lot better to fight off the bacteria. More studies have been done towards them and their purpose is solely to kill off infections.
How?
Step 1- Prepare agar plates. (purchased online)
Step 2- Place a glass beaker on a hot plate with 150ml of water and let boil.
Step 3- Add a tablespoon of each medicine to separate beakers.Let boil for 15 minutes.
Step 4- Remove from heat and let cool.
Step 5- Using the eye dropper take a sample of each solution and place 5 drops into prepared petri dishes.
Step 6- Take sterile swabs and swab hockey gloves. (Using individual swabs)
Step 7- Rub swab onto a petri dish.
Step 8- Place covers on and put in a cool dark place for 4 days or until bacteria is visible.
Step 9- Analyze results.
Materials:
Hot Plates
Glass Beakers
Sterile Swabs
Eye Droppers
Chaga
Muskrat Root
Cedar
Petri Dishes with Agar
Amoxicillin
Water
Timer
Hockey gloves
What?
As you can see the sample that grew the least amount of bacteria is the Amoxicillin. While Cedar, Chaga, and Muskrat root grew more bacteria then the control. With Cedar growing the most bacteria out of them all.
Muskrat root has a pain relieving effect and is used to fight off colds, upset stomach, and fevers. By taking a piece of muskrat root and chewing it. It is found in wetlands such as swamps and marshes.
Chaga Mushroom helps fight off illnesses, lower cholesterol, lowers stress. High cholesterol risks heart disease, therefore chaga mushroom can help fight off cardiovascular disease. Chaga grows on Birch trees throughout the northern hemisphere.
Cedar helps fight against diseases and clearing congestion. It is often used in sweatlodges to line the floor. Cedar is found on trees in cool moist climates.
Amoxicillin is an antibiotic used to treat bacterial infections such as pneumonia and bronchitis. Works within 2-3 days. Must be prescribed from a healthcare provider.
So What?
Though I have no doubt that the traditional medicines work and have worked in the past to fight off infection. I believe that modern day medicines will work a lot better to fight off the bacteria. More studies have been done towards them and their purpose is solely to kill off infections.
What's Next?
In the future I would like to continue to study the effects of traditional medicines on bacterial growth. I would like to include more traditionall medicines and work with a mentor to count the bacterial growth as well as determine the type of bacteria growing.
Thanks
I would like to thank everyone who helped me with this project. Inlcuding those that helped supply the materials and helped with the procedure which include my principal, teachers and family.
References
https://www.muiniskw.org/pgCulture2a.htm
https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/mikmaq-community-helper-shares-knowledge-of-sacred-plants-117069
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/traditional-plants-elder-cecelia-brooks-1.6082674
https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/drugs/20668-amoxicillin-capsules-or-tablets
Images (15)
Awards (1)
- Selected for CWSF 2026
Competition history
- CWSF 2026
Related projects
ISEF · 2022
New Research, Old Medicine: Exploring Antibacterial Properties of Plants and Fungi Used in Indigenous Medicine
CYSF · 2025
Battle of the cures
ISEF · 2018
Returning to Roots: A Study on the Antibacterial Properties of Herbal Extracts Found in Traditional Chinese Medicine
ISEF · 2016
Alternative Medicines in the Treatment of MRSA and Staphylococcus aureus
ISEF · 2018
Investigating an Alternative Treatment Protocol for Commonly Occurring Pathogenic Bacteria: Escherichia coli, Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus, and Listeria monocytogenes
ISEF · 2022
Antibiotics vs. Essential Oils
ISEF · 2024
Antibiotics vs. Bacteria (pt 3)
ISEF · 2014
Let Food Be Your Medicine and Medicine Be Your Food
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.