To "E" or Not to "E"
CSEF · 2012 Product Science (Biological) (Junior Division Only) Fourth Award
Overview
Objectives/Goals The goal of this project is to determine which type of reading platform is better: Back-lit (LCD) eReader, Non- Back- lit (eInk)eReader, and a book. Methods/Materials There are 2 parts to this experiment: Part One, Health and Part Two, Comprehension. For part one, subjects come to test site late at night and have their eyes tested for redness and soreness. Then subjects will alternate reading an Ipad (LCD), a Kobo (eInk), and a book for one hour per reader and then be checked for redness and soreness again. For part two, subjects read material from one of the three readers and then took a test on it. All that was needed was a camera, an Ipad, a Kobo, and a book. Results For part one, the Kobo did worst by .33 on a scale of 1 to 10, then the Ipad and Book tied. For part two, the Ipad did by far worst with the subjects averaging a test score of 4 and the Kobo being second with an average and book being best for comprehension. Conclusions/Discussion In order to determine which of the readers was best, it had to succeed in both parts of the experiment. For part one, the Kobo lost the race by being the worst for your eyes and the Ipad and book tied. For part two, the Ipad also lost the race with the Kobo being a pathetic second and the book by far beating everything else. In conclusion, the book is the best type of reading platform made today.
Summary statement
My project is on how eReaders in comparison to books effect the health of your eye and your comprehension.
Help received
Parents helped edit report; had 18 subjects be in experimentation.
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2012
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2014
The Great Reading Mystery: Was It the Book or Was It the Tablet?
CSEF · 2014
iPad vs. Text
CSEF · 2018
Is Technology Good for Us After All?
CSEF · 2011
Read All About It: Does Reading from a Printed Page vs. a Digital Screen Affect Reading Comprehension?
CSEF · 2013
The Effects of Traditional Printers Black Ink and Electronic Ink as Used on a Kindle on Reading Comprehension
CSEF · 2014
Digital Dilemma: An Analysis of Print vs. Digital Text
CSEF · 2002
E-World versus Real World, Reading Comprehension
CSEF · 2016
Electronic Media vs. Paper: Effect on Teenagers' Reading Comprehension
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects