What Material Provides the Best Protection for Your Electronic Device?
CSEF · 2018 Materials Science (Junior Division Only)
Overview
Objectives/Goals My project was to determine what material provides the best protection for an electronic device when dropped on to asphalt. I believe that the styrofoam cover will provide the most protection. Methods/Materials Ten identical calculators (brand, size and shape), and nine different materials provided protection. The nine different materials were 1) an air pouch, 2) cotton, 3) cardboard, 4) neoprene, 5) silicone, 6) styrofoam, 7) leather, 8) foam craft sheet, and 9) plastic. One calculator was left unprotected. Calculators securely covered in the selected materials. Dropped each calculator (face up) ten times from the height of 54 inches over asphalt, to determine which material provided the most protection. Results The calculator with the styrofoam cover provided the most protection to physical damage, while the calculator with the plastic cover saw the same amount of damage as the unprotected calculator. The other materials provided varying levels of protection. Conclusions/Discussion The protection provided by the styrofoam cover was more effective than the eight other materials tested, leaving the the least amount of signs of physical damage. Further studies in electronic device cases could one day result in a perfect case. for now, and until further research, many still struggle in finding the best case for their electronic device.
Summary statement
I tested what common materials provided the best protection for your electronic device against everyday situations.
Help received
I developed and conducted the tests myself, and my science fair advisor (Mrs.Stead) directed me to helpful sources.
Competition history
- CSEF 2018
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2013
The Most Force Absorbent Material
CSEF · 2011
Fragile: Handle with Care. Which Packing Material Is the Best?
CSEF · 2004
Quality of Packing Material
CSEF · 2008
Which Packing Material Is Best?
CSEF · 2009
Handle with Care: Testing the Effectiveness of Different Packaging
CSEF · 2011
Impact Absorption
CSEF · 2014
Will the Egg Break?
CSEF · 2017
Testing the Effectiveness of Mycofoam as an Eco-Friendly Packing Material
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects