The Effect of Football Helmet Inflation on Energy Absorbance
CSEF · 2016 Applied Mechanics & Structures
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective of this experiment was to determine the effect of football helmet inflation on the amount of energy that the helmet absorbed. Methods/Materials In order to test the hypothesis, an anatomically accurate human analog head was constructed using a mannequin head which was hollowed out and the cranium was replaced with a coconut shell while the remaining space inside the head was filled with simulated cerebrospinal fluid. An accelerometer was placed inside the head and secured to a modeled brain stem. It was used to determine the forces exerted on the human brain and the head was placed inside of a Shutt DNA football helmet. The helmet was then struck in the same place by an air powered pneumatic cylinder pressurized to the same 550 kPa each time to ensure maximum consistency. Results It was found that at lower helmet pressures the energy absorbance was slightly higher (approx. 0.3% difference). At 100% inflation, 99.25% of the energy was absorbed whereas at 80% inflation, 99.34% was absorbed; at 60% inflation, 99.46% was absorbed; at 40% inflation, 99.47% was absorbed; at 20% inflation, 99.48% was absorbed; and at 0% inflation, 99.51% was absorbed. The average deviation was found to be extremely low at 0.026%. Conclusions/Discussion Under normal circumstances the 0.3% difference would have likely been deemed inconclusive, however the human brain is so delicate that this seemingly small energy difference could have a profound clinical impact; especially when considering that for professional players, 0.3% of the impact is still a difference of nearly 7 newtons.
Summary statement
I demonstrated that by lowering the inflation pressure within a football helmet, the risk of a player getting a concussion could be lowered.
Help received
I did the majority of the work myself, however I received help with the research from Kalli Ickes, A.T.C and Dr. Jonathan Minor, M.D. I also received aid on my experimental design from my stepfather, Ryan Jonson, who is a mechanical engineer.
Competition history
- CSEF 2016
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2015
A Novel Design and Evaluation of an Air Cushioning Mechanism for Helmets to Reduce Impact Acceleration on the Head
CSEF · 2013
Concussion Cushion
CSEF · 2014
The Effect of Different Impact Absorbing Materials on a Simulated Human Head Model
CSEF · 2006
Get Your Head in the Game
CSEF · 2013
Football: Coming to a Crashing Halt
ISEF · 2015
Investigating External Interventions Applied to Football Headgear to Decrease Mean Peak Acceleration as Measured by a Single Axis Accelerometer Array
CSEF · 2013
A Better Way to Prevent Concussions: The Addition of Non-Newtonian Fluids to Helmet Padding
AJAS · 2019
Enhancing the Biomechanical Design of Football Helmets (Concussion Prevention) Part 3
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects