Less-Toxic Herbicide Alternatives
CSEF · 2002 Pharmacology/ Toxicology
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective of our project was to determine which of four less-toxic herbicide alternatives would kill Bermudagrass most efficiently over a five-day period. We believed that St.Gabriel Laboratory#s Fast Acting BurnOut Weed and Grass Killer would work most effectively due to its technique of killing vegetation through a burn-down process by binding to the plant cell structure. Methods/Materials We divided fifteen sections (25.4 x 38.1 cm) of Bermudagrass using 20.7 meters of wood strips to segregate the areas. Each of the following alternatives were used on three separate sections: St.Gabriel Laboratory#s Fast Acting BurnOut Weed and Grass Killer (vinegar and lemon juice components), Bioganic Weed and Grass Killer, (eugenol oil), Safer Brand Weed and Grass Killer (potassium salts), and 4.5 liters of boiling water (per square). Three squares were left untouched as our control. To fully protect ourselves during application, we wore work gloves, safety glasses, long sleeve shirts, and long pants. We took photos of the Bermudagrass patches immediately after the initial application and the following five consecutive days. Results On day-five of our testing period, Safer Brand Weed and Grass Killer had killed and disintegrated all the grass, leaving exposed soil behind. St. Gabriel Laboratory#s Fast Acting BurnOut Weed and Grass Killer had killed all the grass and caused the majority to dry up, leaving partially exposed soil. Bioganic Weed and Grass Killer had killed the grass and it had just started to break down to expose soil. Boiling water killed the grass but the majority of the dead debris remained. In our control areas, where no alternatives were applied, the grass had stayed healthy. Conclusions/Discussion After the five-day period Safer Brand Weed and Grass Killer had killed the grass most efficiently. Our hypothesis was incorrect. Although St. Gabriel Laboratory#s Fast Acting BurnOut Weed and Grass Killer had killed the grass well, it just didn#t do it as quickly as Safer Brand. Even boiling water killed the grass. The fact that all four methods killed the grass proves that less-toxic alternatives work well. Highly toxic herbicides, which can harm human health and the environment, aren#t as necessary as people assume them to be.
Summary statement
Our project tests the effectiveness of less-toxic herbicide alternatives on Bermudagrass over a five-day period.
Help received
Jaimie's mother (a Master Gardener) suggested research materials during our interview with her.
Competition history
- CSEF 2002
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2012
Natural vs. Chemical Herbicides
CSEF · 2018
Are There Effective Alternatives to Full Strength Roundup?
CSEF · 2011
How Will Diluted Concentrations of Heated Herbicide Affect the Killing of Plants?
CSEF · 2004
Weed Killers: Effectiveness and Harm to the Environment
CSEF · 2018
Using Adjuvants to Amplify the Effect of Organic Herbicides to Kill Undesired Plants
CSEF · 2012
Commercial vs. Non-commercial Weed Killers: Which Works the Fastest?
CSEF · 2017
Investigating the Effectiveness of Natural Herbicides in Killing Pest Plants
CSEF · 2009
Safe or Sorry?
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects