Green Tea: Do More Expensive Green Teas Have a Better Medical Effect?
CSEF · 2006 Pharmacology/ Toxicology
Overview
Objectives/Goals My objective was to determine whether more expensive green tea types were more effective in reducing heartbeat rates in Daphnia than cheaper varieties of green tea. Methods/Materials I tallied the heartbeat rates of Daphnia samples thirty times each in water and in green teas (five different kinds ranging from $0.15 per 2 grams to $2.00 per 2 grams). A Daphnia was placed on a microscope with a drop of water and the number of the Daphnia#s heartbeats was counted in five seconds. The result was multiplied by twelve to determine the Daphnia#s heartbeat rates in one minute in water. Then, the number of Daphnia#s heartbeats was counted in the green tea concentrate. This process was repeated 30 times each per green tea (5 different kinds) to collect enough sample data (total of 300 samples). The quality and the cost (unit price per 2 grams of green tea) of the green teas are: Tea #1 (grounded in a tea bag, $0.15), Tea #2 (bulk and large mature leaves, $0.20), Tea #3 (better quality mature leaves, $0.30), Tea #4 (small early leaves in a luxury package, $1.00), and Tea #5 (very small baby leaves in a luxury package, $2.00). Results In my testing, the average reduction in heartbeats of Daphnia exposed to each green tea sample were: Tea #1 (32.8 beats per minute), Tea #2 (34.0 bpm), Tea #3 (34.0 bpm), Tea #4 (28.0 bpm), and Tea #5 (32.8 bpm). It showed that the larger and more mature green tea leaves (#2 and #3) are more effective in lowering heartbeat rates than the younger and smaller leaves (#4 and #5). It means that the cheaper green teas are more effective in lowering heartbeat rates than the more expensive ones. Conclusions/Discussion My hypothesis was not supported because the cheaper green teas showed better heartbeat rate reduction results than the more expensive ones. The Daphnia#s heartbeat rate was slower with Green Teas Samples #2 and #3 than with Green Teas Sample #4 and #5. It seems to me that the larger and mature leaves have more chemical ingredients than younger and smaller leaves. However, the taste of the expensive green teas is much better than the cheaper varieties# taste, giving a better, more luxurious, and longer-lasting taste.
Summary statement
This project is to determine whether more expensive green teas have better medical effectiveness than cheaper varieties in reducing heartbeat rates on Daphnia (and perhaps even humans).
Help received
Many thanks to my mom and dad for transportation, funds, and making green teas; Mr. Hodges and Ms. Herrington (science teachers) for their advice and mentoring; and my sister Eunice for her help on editing my work and giving me advice.
Awards (1)
- Category Award
Competition history
- CSEF 2006
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2005
Green Tea: An Effective Alternative in Reducing Heartbeat Rates as Compared to Prescription Medicine
CSEF · 2007
The Teeter-Totter of Tea
CSEF · 2011
A Monster Problem? The Effect of Caffeinated Drinks on Heart Rate
CSEF · 2003
The Telltale Heart: The Effect of Various Stimulants on the Heart Rate of Daphnia magna
CSEF · 2013
Energy Drinks: Heart Safe or Heart Stopping?
CSEF · 2016
The Effects of Various Concentrations of Sotalol and Caffeine on the Heart Rate of Daphnia magna
CSEF · 2012
The Toxic Effects of Teas as Pesticides or Repellents on Lumbricus rubellus, Genus Helix, and Genus Deroceras
CSEF · 2016
Got Antioxidants? Using Chemiluminescence to Study the Effect of Adding Milk or Sugar on the Antioxidant Level of Tea
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects