Do Environmentally Friendly Dish Soaps Clean Oil Off Feathers as Well as Dawn?
CSEF · 2019 Product Science (Biological) (Junior Division Only) Third Award
Overview
Objectives My objective is to evaluate the effectiveness of dish soaps in removing oil from bird feathers in case of an oil spill. Dawn Ultra Dish Soap is the current standard for cleaning birds, but is known to have petroleum as a trace ingredient. I want to see if one of the new, more environmentally friendly dish soaps will perform as well or better than Dawn. Methods Feathers, 4 different dish soaps, digital scale, synthetic motor oil, pipettes, protective gloves. Weighed 5 feathers for each brand of dish soap before applying oil, after applying oil and after each of two cleanings. Measured percent of oil removed for each trial to determine effectiveness of dish soap. Results Removing oil from feathers is difficult, none of the dish soaps removed more than 33% of the oil after the first cleaning. After two cleanings Dawn removed 67% of the oil and the best environmentally friendly dish soap only removed 55% with the remaining two only removing about 33%. Dawn performed best in both cleaning stages. Conclusions Dawn Ultra was the best dish soap I tested at removing oil from bird feathers. The more environmentally friendly dish soaps did not perform as well. My results show Dawn Ultra should remain the standard for cleaning oil soaked birds.
Summary statement
I found that Dawn Ultra dish soap should remain the standard for cleaning oil soaked birds, none of the more environmentally friendly dish soaps removed oil from feathers as effectively.
Help received
Curt Clumpner, Deputy Director, Animal Care Operations, Oiled Wildcare Network, UC Davis, suggested articles for me to read. My parents helped me get supplies and supported me with timing and measurements while I conducted the experiment.
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2019
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2015
Soap Wars: Comparing Dishwashing Liquids in Oil Spill Cleanups
CSEF · 2002
Which Product Removes the Most Oil from Oil Soaked Feathers?
CSEF · 2014
Oil Spill Clean Up
CSEF · 2006
A Method to Quantify the Efficacy of Solvents to Remove Petroleum Contamination from Avian Plumage
CSEF · 2008
The Oil Effect: The Removal of Oil from Bird Feathers using Common Household Solvents
CSEF · 2014
Bioremediation vs. Chemical Cleaning of Oiled Birds and the Effluent
CSEF · 2003
Like Water off a Duck's Back
CSEF · 2011
Our Sticky Situation: Household Dispersants and the Gulf Oil Spill
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects