Bioremediation vs. Chemical Cleaning of Oiled Birds and the Effluent
CSEF · 2014 Environmental Engineering (Junior Division Only) Third Award
Overview
Objectives/Goals My objective was to determine if a top bioremediation agent, (OSEII -the only 1st response EPA listed bioremediation agent) used for cleaning oil spills could be applied to the cleaning of oiled birds and perform as effectively or better than the top chemical cleaning agent (DAWN- used for the past 30 yrs.) in cleaning oiled birds and remediating the effluent. Methods/Materials I designed and implemented a procedure based in part on the internationally accepted cleaning protocol of oiled birds at treatment facilities. I used three different types of feathers (Primary/ Contour/ Down) and expanded the research to include treatment of the effluent produced during the cleaning process. Light crude was used so no pretreating was necessary. All feathers were soaked in oil for 5min., blotted and weighed Each feather was then submerged in 1 wash/1 rinse solution of 50mL of each cleaning agent to 500mL. of water (51.2mg/L hardness) heated to 40ºc. and 1 wash/rinse control consisting of water with no cleaning agent Each wash/rinse cycle was timed for 10 min. with agitation for .5min at 1, 5 &10min. Feathers were removed, blotted once and hung to dry for 2hrs then weighed again. All cleaning and rinse water was then added to three aerated 10gal aquariums containing 5 gal of water (51.2mg/L hardness) each. Water levels were marked and temperatures recorded. Aquariums with effluent were monitored for 30 days. Results The bioremediation agent removed 3% more oil than the chemical agent and completely detoxified the effluent leaving only CO2 and water. The chemical agent cleaned the feathers leaving slightly more residue but showed no remediation of the effluent. The control neither cleaned the feathers nor remediated the effluent. Conclusions/Discussion I feel these results may indicate the possibility of a less stressful protocol for cleaning oiled birds due to the reduction in handling time (fewer rinse tubs and no final spray rinse), a reduced amount of effluent (a typical oiled bird requires an average of 2 to 300gal. of water to clean) and a protocol that can at the same time remediate the effluent so there is no need for further toxic waste treatment.
Summary statement
My project was testing to see if a top bioremediation agent could perform as well or better than a top chemical agent in cleaning oiled birds and remediating the effluent.
Help received
Mother helped type report, purchase needed equipment and display board materials, and took pictures during my experiment.
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2014
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2006
A Method to Quantify the Efficacy of Solvents to Remove Petroleum Contamination from Avian Plumage
CSEF · 2015
Testing the Adhesive and Toxic Properties of Bioremediated Oil
CSEF · 2008
The Oil Effect: The Removal of Oil from Bird Feathers using Common Household Solvents
CSEF · 2019
Do Environmentally Friendly Dish Soaps Clean Oil Off Feathers as Well as Dawn?
CSEF · 2014
Oil Spill Clean Up
CSEF · 2015
Soap Wars: Comparing Dishwashing Liquids in Oil Spill Cleanups
CSEF · 2002
Oil Spill Clean-up: Moving or Removing Oil?
CSEF · 2002
Which Product Removes the Most Oil from Oil Soaked Feathers?
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects