Exploring Academic Setting Applications of a Turing Test Derivative
CSEF · 2023 Behavioral & Social Sciences First Award
Overview
Chat GPT is a groundbreaking Artificial Intelligence (AI) application that can write essays in under a minute. Since its release in November 2022, it has sparked a worldwide debate about its use in the classroom. My hypothesis was that teachers and students would not be able to distinguish between essays written by humans or generated by ChatGPT. To test this hypothesis, I conducted a survey experiment which asked 260 participants; 185 teachers and 75 students to determine whether essays were written by human authors or AI. Participants’ average success rate was 49.81%, which is statistically indistinguishable from chance. Most control variables such as teaching experience, gender, or awareness of ChatGPT had little effect on scores. The most common strategies used by participants, moreover, are the easiest to circumvent using Chat GPT. These findings raise serious questions about the future of education amidst an AI revolution.
Source coverage
This record comes from a published award list, not a complete project archive. Its abstract comes from CSEF's public project showcase as archived by the Internet Archive before judging (https://web.archive.org/web/20230401224130/https://ca-csef.zfairs.com/showcase/ShowcaseInfo?f=838e60b7-ea75-46e8-865c-fde4864244b3); the version presented may differ.
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2023
Resources
Related projects
ISEF · 2024
A Novel Approach to Detecting Academic Dishonesty Involving Artificial Intelligence
CYSF · 2025
The Mystery Of AI Writing
CSEF · 2026
Trusting Minds vs. Machines
ISEF · 2023
Artificial Genius: Testing the Abilities of Artificial Intelligence in a More Turing Way
CYSF · 2026
Can You Spot the Bot? Testing AI Detector Accuracy, Patterns and Use with Human, Humanized and AI Texts
ISEF · 2025
Authorship Verification for Academic Dishonesty in the Era of AI
CSEF · 2026
Does AI Have Personality?
CYSF · 2025
Trained AI vs Teachers
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects