Which Type of Paper Tray Dehydrates Grapes the Fastest?
CSEF · 2019 Product Science (Biological) (Junior Division Only) Fourth Award
Overview
Objectives The Objective of my project is comparing various paper tray types: Wet Strength, Wet Strength Vented, Poly Coated, Poly Vented, and Poly Coated Slitted Vented to see which type drys grapes the fastest. My goal is to prove that Coated trays will have have a faster drying time than the non-Coated trays. Also taking the coated trays benefit of protecting the grapes from rain into consideration. Methods The materials I used in my experiment were a scale, 2 picking knives, a wooden tray, 4 trays of each tray type, and a picking pan. The first step I took in doing my procedure was purchasing the different tray types from Michelson Packaging company in Fresno. The trays I purchased were the Wet Strength, Poly Coated, Poly Vented, and Poly Coated Slitted Vented paper trays. After doing this, I poked holes in the Wet Strength tray, with the fowling measurements: 13 rows, 16 holes in each row, 5 centimeters apart covering the entire tray to create the Wet Strength Vented tray. I then picked 8,165 grams of grapes for each tray. I had 5 tray types and 4 trays for each type, and had a total of 20 trays. Lastly, I let the grapes dehydrate for 7 days, and weighed the grapes on the different tray types. Repeated this procedure 7 days later for my final results for tray drying rate average. Results The result of my experiment showed that the Wet Strength tray had the highest impact on drying grapes; the final weight average of the tray was 1,719 grams. The 2nd best tray type was the Wet Strength Vented tray at 1,798 gram average. The third best tray type was the Poly Coated Slitted Vented tray with an average weight of 1,826 grams. The 4th best tray type was the Poly Coated tray at a weight of 2,090 gram average. The worst tray for dehydrating grapes was the Poly Vented tray type, at a 2,219 gram average. This information proves my Hypothesis was incorrect. Conclusions After Completing my investigation, I can conclude my Hypothesis was incorrect. My experiment Showed that both Non-Coated trays had a higher impact on drying than the Coated trays. Comparing the Wet Strength tray to the Poly Coated slitted vented, The Wet Strength had a 6% faster dehydration speed. Comparing The Wet Strength tray to the Poly Coated, I found that the Wet Strength tray had a 18% faster drying rate, which is significant. When comparing the Wet Strength tray to the Poly Vented tray, it dried 22% faster, which is also Significant. In a 40 acre Vineyard Wet Strength would cost $2000 vs. $3,800 for Poly Coated or Vented. Although, the Wet strength tray may have the best dehydration speed and cost the
Summary statement
The Wet Strength paper tray proved to dehydrated grapes the fastest with more crop risk, vs poly Coated trays with less crop risk.
Help received
Mrs. Florence Peters, Ranch Owner ;Chad Gregerson , Michaelson Packaging Fresno, Salesman
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2019
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2014
Is Darker Better?
CSEF · 2002
A Thirst For Spills: Tests of Paper Towel Fiber Structures
CSEF · 2007
The Hidden Strength of Paper Towels
CSEF · 2002
Environmental Factors Affecting Transpiration / To Transpire or Not to Transpire: That Is the Question
CSEF · 2019
Investigating Different Fabrics on Water Absorption, Drying Time, and Drying Cost
CSEF · 2006
Effects of Different Fabrics Inhibiting the Passage of Moisture from the Environment
CSEF · 2011
Ri-i-i-i-i-i-ip! Which Paper Towels Are the Strongest and Most Absorbent?
CSEF · 2012
Determining the Cost Efficiency and Water Conservation of Various Irrigation Methods
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects