Which Paper Towel Gives You the Most Bang for Your Buck?
CSEF · 2005 Materials Science (Junior Division Only)
Overview
Objectives/Goals My project was designed to test whether higher cost in paper towels meant higher quality or not. Methods/Materials To test absorbency, I put a paper towel into a 6-inch plastic embroidery hoop and put it on a clear bucket so that only the plastic hoop was touching the bucket. Then I dropped one drop of water at a time into the center of the paper towel, at about one per second. When one drop dripped out the bottom of the paper towel, I would stop counting and record my data. I did this for three times per brand. To test strength, I would take the wet paper towel that was wet enough to drop one drop of water or more out of the bottom, and put penny after penny into the center of the paper towel until the paper towel ripped and pennies spilled out the bottom. I then recorded my data and repeated twice more. Materials- 1.Nine different brands of paper towels from a standard supermarket 2.A dropper 3.Water 4.Pennies 5.Plastic embroidery hoop 6.Clear tub with the bottom cut out 7.Recording sheets and writing instruments Results At the three cheapest, Slim Price, Earth First, and Vons, my hypothesis fit perfectly. Most of the medium priced paper towels also followed my hypothesis. But the best paper towel, Thirsty, was very inexpensive, and the most expensive paper towel, Viva, was shown as not that good. Conclusions/Discussion The paper towels in the study, although don#t follow my hypothesis exactly, mainly follow my hypothesis. It is mostly only two of the paper towels that are wacky. The best performing paper towel is in the low-medium price range and the most expensive paper towel is medium quality.
Summary statement
I used two tests on nine paper towel brands to determine the quality, then compared the results to the costs.
Help received
Mom helped getting supplies, typing, and cutting and glueing; Dad cut out the bottom of a clear plastic tub.
Competition history
- CSEF 2005
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2007
The Hidden Strength of Paper Towels
CSEF · 2011
Ri-i-i-i-i-i-ip! Which Paper Towels Are the Strongest and Most Absorbent?
CSEF · 2013
Wiping Up the Competition
CSEF · 2010
The Big, the Bad, and the Brawny: Paper Towel Absorbency
CSEF · 2002
A Thirst For Spills: Tests of Paper Towel Fiber Structures
CSEF · 2019
Toilet Paper Absorbency
CSEF · 2010
Paper Towels, Cloths, or Chamois: Which One Is More Absorbent?
CSEF · 2002
Which Paper Is Better for You and Your Tank?
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects