The Relationship between Deception and Altruism amongst Teens of Different Economic Status
CSEF · 2019 Behavioral & Social Sciences
Overview
Objectives This experiment was performed to investigate whether the economic status of young adults affect a tendency to lie for personal gain, or for the benefits of others. A preliminary survey was sent out to 58 high school-age teens to get a representation of the data the experiment could produce. The survey showed that 2.05% of people whose families struggled financially have a tendency to lie to benefit themselves, while 19.0% of people whose families are financially stable have the same tendency. The actual experiment, which included a survey that included multiple scenarios with decisions that allowed participants a choice between exuding a generous, honest behavior, or a selfish, deceptive behavior. A total of 105 teens in Ventura County took the survey, with about 28 of participants exuding a selfish, deceptive behavior. Out of these 28, 18 participants were of a high economic status, while 10 participants were of a low economic status. To determine whether a participant was of a high or economic class, participants were asked to state if their families owned more or less than $80,000, which is the average income of a Ventura County household. The original hypothesis that teens of a higher economical class were more likely to lie to benefit themselves was proven to be correct. Not only was the hypothesis proven to be correct, but the stereotype society has instilled on the behaviors of lower class teens was as well. Society thinks today that teens of a lower economic class are more likely to lie or steal, however the experiment has shown this to be invalid and solely based off one s opinions, not fact. Methods Google survey (questions created by us), social media accounts Results A total of 105 participants in Ventura County took the survey on social media, however 89 participants were taken into consideration, due to insufficient answers or responses. Out of these 89 participants, 29 individuals families currently have an income less than $80,000 a year, while 60 individuals families earned more than $80,000. For the purposes of this experiment, results show that teens of lower economic statuses have a greater tendency to develop selfish, deceptive tendencies rather than teens of higher economic statuses. Out of these 89 participants, 28 teens communicated selfish, deceptive answers while 61 teens communicated altruistic, honest answers, out of a total of 7 different scenarios. Out of those 28 individuals who communicated selfish, deceptive answers, 18 were of a higher economic status than the average family household in Ventura County, while 10 were of a lower economic status. Conclusions
Summary statement
The stereotype that someone who is poor will steal more than someone who is rich is not aplicable and should not be taught to children to further advance to a unified society.
Competition history
- CSEF 2019
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2011
Who Lies More, Boys or Girls?
CSEF · 2015
Money and the Mind: How Does Someone's Economic Situation Affect Their Moral Decision Making?
CSEF · 2013
Altruism, Cognitive Function, and Self-Esteem
CSEF · 2012
San Carlos Teens Solve National Debt Crisis
CSEF · 2018
Perceptions and Decisions about Cheating: A Cross-Institutional Comparison
CSEF · 2015
Exploring and Comparing the Effects of Reward and Punishment
CSEF · 2004
Do People Perform on Tests the Way They Think Is Expected of Them?
CSEF · 2010
To Lie or Not to Lie: That Is the Question
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects