The Effect of Macronutrient Splits on the Loss of Visceral Fat

CSEF · 2017 Mammalian Biology

Overview

Objectives/Goals The objective is to determine if there is a difference in visceral fat lost through three different macronutrient splits: normal (40%carbohydrates/30%fats/30%proteins), high carbohydrate (55% carbohydrates/15%fats/30%proteins), and high fat(25%carbohydrates/35%fats/30% proteins.) Methods/Materials Materials required were 15 human subjects, a scale, a computer, and access to Avatar Nutrition. We weighed each subject and found their maintenance calories and fiber requirements. Each of the subjects were split into the 3 splits and told them to maintain their activity level. After 3 weeks of dieting, the subjects were weighed again. After the results, we ran a T-test. Results The average visceral fat lost was .72% through all groups. The normal group lost 1.06%, the high carbohydrate group lost 2.2%, and the high-fat group lost 0% visceral fat on average. The difference between the high carbohydrate and high fat group was the only test proven to be significant through a T-test. Conclusions/Discussion The Normal Diet proved to be in the middle of the other two diets due to it being based off of the average unhealthy American#s diet. The visceral fat loss was just as we expected. In the High fat split, the subjects lost weight as expected but lost more subcutaneous fat than visceral fat. This split did not work for losing much visceral fat because lipids go through a longer process to convert into glucose so it became Visceral fat. The High Carbohydrate diet led to a larger percent in visceral fat loss. In addition, less subcutaneous fat was lost. This could have been because of the fast process of using Carbohydrates as energy. A T-Test was conducted to see if these results were significant but all except one lacked enough evidence to prove significance. This was due to the lack of subjects and not being able to fulfill the Central Limit Theorem. The results still hold value to them and show that the high carbohydrate split led to the greatest loss in visceral fat.

Summary statement

Our project found that the high carbohydrate split was the best way to lose the fat held around organs which can help solve many of the health drawbacks that are associated with visceral fat, such as Heart disease and Type 2 Diabetes.

Help received

My biology teacher helped us conduct a t-test on the subjects. Layne Norton, PhD in nutrition, reviewed our methods and suggests helpful changes to the experiment so that we could improve it.

Competition history

  • CSEF 2017 Mammalian Biology · Entry S1302

Resources

Related projects

Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.

Browse more like this

Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects

Save projects to your library

Sign in with Google to keep track of projects you find interesting, organized into folders. An account also raises your daily allowance for “Has this been done?”, and lets you create a key for the MCP server with a much higher limit than anonymous use. Browsing stays public.

Continue with Google