Switch Craft: Is the Switch Strategy Still Optimal When the Monte Hall Game Is Expanded to More Than Three Doors?
CSEF · 2017 Mathematical Sciences
Overview
Objectives/Goals It is well established that a "switch strategy" gives you a better chance of winning a prize in the traditional 3-door Monte Hall Problem. The objective of this study was to see if the "switch strategy" would still be preferred if you played the game with more than three doors. Additionally the goal was to see how the statistical chances of winning would change and could be predicted. Methods/Materials Cups, toy goats, toy car, computer, Microsoft Excel. Wrote a code to simulate playing the game on a computer automatically. Use this to show the results from playing the game 10 times, 100 times, 1000 times etc. up to 1,000,000 times. Results The "switch strategy" gave you a better chance of winning the prize, even when the game was played with more than three doors. Conclusions/Discussion I predicted a formula for the chances of winning if you played with "n" doors and always switched. That formula is (n-1)/n.
Summary statement
I simulated millions of rounds of the famous Monte Hall game with various numbers of doors then proposed a formula for the chances of winning if you switch.
Help received
Jennifer Parker, Bryn Dombkowski, Ashley Dombkowski
Competition history
- CSEF 2017
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2013
To Switch or Not to Switch? That Is the Question: The Monty Hall Problem
ISEF · 2026
Goat a Feeling I Should Switch: A Study of Whether Switching Doors in the Monty Hall Problem Increases Your Chances of Winning
CSEF · 2013
The Monty Hall Problem
CSEF · 2005
Let's Make a Deal
CSEF · 2014
Monty Hall in Megabytes
ISEF · 2015
Using Statistical Analysis and Probability to Examine a Counterintuitive Problem
CSEF · 2006
Let's Make A Deal: The Monty Hall Theory
CSEF · 2002
Let's Make a Deal: A Ratio Problem
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects