Sweeten Your Knowledge: The Search for the Perfect Sugar Substitute
CSEF · 2010 Product Science (Biological) (Junior Division Only) First Award
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective of my project was to determine which artificial sweetener achieves the lowest calorie content without sacrificing taste. Methods/Materials One mass scale balance was used to measure 12 different types of sweeteners. Baker's Yeast, Ziploc plastic sandwich bags, and measuring cups were used to ferment the sweeteners. The amount of carbon dioxide produced when the sweeteners fermented demonstrated the relative amount of calories. The three sugars with the least amount of calories, as well as refined sugar as a base line, were used in a taste test. In the taste test, I recorded the responses of a group of 30 human subjects to samples of each sweetener. Subjects were asked to rate each sweetener on a sweetness scale of 0 -3 and whether they would use each sweetener. Results While most sweeteners produced significant amounts of carbon dioxide, Truvia, Purevia and Splenda showed almost no fermentation. On the taste test, sugar was by far the most popular, but Splenda performed the best out of the non-sugar sweeteners. Conclusions/Discussion Artificial sweetners are a billion dollar industry with huge advertising campaigns that can sometimes be misleading. My results clearly show that three artificial sweeteners, Purevia, Truvia and Splenda, were most truthful about their calorie content whereas other sweeteners were not as acccurate in their representations. Out of these three lower calorie sweeteners, Splenda was the most popular to human subjects.
Summary statement
This project focused on product testing of taste and calorie content in sugar substitutes
Help received
Mother helped with setting up the statistical analysis and conducting the taste test. Father helped with setting up yeast test.
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2010
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2013
Sweeteners and Sweetness: Is There a Non-Harmful, but Tasty, Sweetener for Teens?
CSEF · 2014
Lemonade: The Sweet Solution
CSEF · 2012
Sugar Anyone? A Comparison of Natural and Artificial Sweeteners and the Effects on Blood Glucose
CSEF · 2013
Yeast + Sugar Substitutes: Rise or Fall?
CSEF · 2019
Sugar Rush: Good to Eat a Bunch?
CSEF · 2003
Yeasts 'n Sweets
CSEF · 2006
Which Sweetener Tastes Best? Which Is Best for You? A Comparison of Five Sweeteners
CSEF · 2012
Carbon Catcher
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects