Save Our Beaches: Man-Made vs. Natural Erosion Prevention Solutions
CSEF · 2016 Earth & Atmospheric Sciences (Junior Division Only)
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective of this study is to determine whether man-made or natural structures are more effective at preventing beach erosion. Methods/Materials 3 plastic bins, beach sand, small rocks, Ceanothus plant, water, and scale. Erosion was simulated for 3 conditions: small rocks with sand, Ceanothus plant with sand, and sand only. The degree of erosion was then assessed by measuring the weight of sand "eroded" in each of the 3 conditions. Results The man-made rock seawall's ability to reduce erosion was tested against the native Ceanothus' plants ability to reduce erosion. After three trials, it was determined that the rock seawall reduced erosion by seven fold while the Ceanothus plant reduced erosion by four fold. Conclusions/Discussion It was concluded that both the seawall and the native plant had a positive impact in preventing erosion. However, the man-made rock seawall was determined to be more effective than the natural Ceanothus plant in preventing beach erosion.
Summary statement
We determined that the man-made rock seawall was more effective than the natural Ceanothus plant in preventing beach erosion.
Help received
My partner and I designed our experiment with the help of Barkev Meserlian, an engineer from the Irvine Ranch Water District. Anthony Malek, a Horticulturist from Roger's Garden, helped us select an appropriate native beach plant.
Competition history
- CSEF 2016
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2019
Sweet Erosion: Analyzing Coastal Erosion Prevention Methods
CSEF · 2026
What Is the Most Effective Method to Reduce Erosion along Cliffsides?
CSEF · 2016
Just Say NO to Erosion!
CSEF · 2012
Chosen for Erosion
CSEF · 2017
The Effectiveness of Commercial Netting in Preventing Erosion
CSEF · 2018
The Best Seawall to Save Our Highways
CSEF · 2003
Reef to the Rescue: Which Artificial Surfing Reef Counteracts Beach Erosion Best?
CSEF · 2016
Man vs. Nature
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects