Retention of Larval Stage Conditioning in Post-Metamorphic Pieris rapae Butterflies
CSEF · 2015 Zoology First Award
Overview
Objectives/Goals My objective was to determine whether Pieris rapae butterflies can retain memories of experiences from their larval stage. Methods/Materials Pieris rapae eggs were obtained and hatched on home-grown radish sprouts. At their 4th instar, they were separated into control and conditioned groups, and were moved into different habitats with organic brussels sprouts. The conditioned group was placed on electrically conductive agarose gel in a container through which the scent of ethyl acetate (EA) was pumped while a mild electric current went through the agarose gel. Following 3 rounds of conditioning, the groups were labeled #A# and #B# so that this would be a blind study for me. The groups were tested (1) to see if the caterpillars had an instinctive aversion to the scent of EA and (2) if not, whether the conditioning had worked such that one group tended to avoid the EA scent. The caterpillars were then allowed to go through metamorphosis. 24 hours after hatching as butterflies, each insect was tested for aversion to the EA scent and then released. The study was repeated three times, each time as a blind study. Group identities were revealed to me only after the completion of the 3rd study. Results Based on my study, Pieris rapae butterflies do not have any instinctive aversion to the scent of EA, but when conditioned to have a negative experience with it, they can and do retain those memories through metamorphosis. Conclusions/Discussion Studies have shown that almost all of a caterpillar#s brain is liquefied during metamorphosis, other than the parts that control certain muscle movement. My study shows that even if the brain matter is liquefied, it has a way of storing memories. Recent studies have also shown that memories are stored not in the synapses, but inside individual neurons. The results of my study are consistent with this recent scientific learning, which could explain how butterflies can recall memories learned prior to metamorphosis.
Summary statement
My project was testing whether Pieris rapae butterflies can retain memories of conditioning from their larval (caterpillar) stage.
Help received
My parents (driving, supplies); family friend (cutting pipes and windows in the butterfly testing apparatus); Cory Tobin (supervision with agarose gel).
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2015
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2007
Butterflies over Pollution
CSEF · 2017
Nonsocial Butterflies: Effects of Social Learning on Flower Foraging in the Nonsocial Cabbage Butterfly (Pieris rapae)
CSEF · 2013
The Effects of Docosahexaenoic Acid on Manduca sexta
CSEF · 2004
The Effects of Classical/Pavlovian Conditioning on Dionaea muscipula
CSEF · 2015
Exploring the Learning Behavior of Pogonomyrmex barbatus Ants in the Absence of Pheromonal Cues
CSEF · 2007
Comparison of Two Mantid Species Exhibiting Parthenogenesis: Iris oratoria and Brunneria borealis
CSEF · 2019
Testing the Oncopeltus fasciatus' Neuromotor Responses to Olfactory and Visual Stimuli
ISEF · 2025
Investigating Global Warming's Impact on the Metamorphosis of Painted Lady Butterflies
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects