Is Green as Clean?
CSEF · 2014 Product Science (Biological) (Junior Division Only)
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective of my project is to find out if green disinfectants are as effective at killing bacteria as regular disinfectants. Methods/Materials Five different disinfectants were used in this experiment, three green and three non-green. The green included Clorox Green Works, Vinegar and water, and Clean Well. the non-green included Lysol, Formula 409, and Windex. Each disinfectant was sprayed on a counter top with raw chicken on it then swabbed and put in an incubator. This was repeated five times and then the average area of bacteria was calculated and analyzed. Results I found that out of my six disinfectants, Formula 409 worked the best, but overall, green disinfectants were more effective than non-green disinfectants. Conclusions/Discussion My hypothesis had two parts to it. It said that Formula 409 would work the best and that chemical disinfectants would be more effective than green disinfectants. However, I found that even though Formula 409 worked the best, green disinfectants were more effective, so my hypothesis was partly correct. Information from this project informs us that we don't have to use harsh chemicals to get rid of bacteria, we can use healthier, safer products to get the job done.
Summary statement
My project is about the effectiveness of "green" disinfectants versus regular disinfectants
Help received
Mom helped with display board, Dad assisted with collecting samples
Competition history
- CSEF 2014
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2009
Is Green Clean or Mean?
CSEF · 2012
Do Green Cleaning Products Get Rid of Bacteria Better Than Ammonia Base Cleaner?
CSEF · 2016
Clorox Wipes vs. Clorox Green Works Wipes: Is Green as Clean?
CSEF · 2012
Bacteria Be Gone! Do Non-Toxic Disinfectants Really Work?
CSEF · 2016
Disinfectants: Environmentally Safe Homemade vs. Toxic Brand-Name Products
CSEF · 2003
Is It Really Clean?
CSEF · 2009
Microbe Busters
CSEF · 2009
Is It Easy Being "Green"? Comparing "Green" and Conventional Cleaners on Environmental Impact, Quality, and Cost
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects