Is a Picture Really Worth a Thousand Words? The Effect of an Illustration on a First Grader's Listening Comprehension
CSEF · 2002 Behavioral Sciences
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective was to discover if first graders have better listening comprehension when viewing an illustration while listening to a story. Methods/Materials A short story, an illustration, and questions were created. One hundred two students were tested. Half were girls and half were boys. Half of the boys and girls were read the story without the picture, and the others viewed the illustration while listening to the story. All were questioned without the illustration. All were individually read the story and tested without distractions from the classroom. After testing all students available, data was calculated and results found. Results Students who viewed the illustration while listening to the story answered four out of the five questions more precisely than students who did not see the illustration. Conclusions/Discussion First graders do have better listening comprehension when they view an illustration while listening to a story. First graders will remember more information if they have a visual aid.
Summary statement
Our project was to find out if viewing an illustration while listening to a story improved a first grader's listening comprehension.
Help received
First grade teachers allowed us to test their students. Parents drove us to the library, elementary school, store for supplies, and each other's home. A college age cousin taught us how to make the graph on the computer.
Competition history
- CSEF 2002
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2011
Is a Picture Worth a Thousand Words?
CSEF · 2004
Do Illustrations Make a Difference in Comprehension?
CSEF · 2006
See This!
CSEF · 2011
Picture This!
CSEF · 2008
Is a Picture Worth a Thousand Words?
CSEF · 2005
Is A Picture Really Worth 1,000 Words?
CSEF · 2004
The Effect of Ready-Made Illustrated Stories on Working Memory
CSEF · 2005
Is a Picture Really Worth a Thousand Words?
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects