Eco-Efficient?
CSEF · 2012 Product Science (Physical) (Junior Division Only)
Overview
Objectives/Goals The objective of the project was to observe the efficiency of green detergents and to determine the most cost-effective detergent. Methods/Materials Materials: Forty-eight 12" by 12" towels, Kenmore 3.6 cubic feet Top Load Washer, Measuring Cup, Heinz Ketchup, Tropicana No Pulp Premium Ornage Juice, Coffee, Mud, Tide Original, Gain Original, Seventh Generation Original, Green Works Original. Method: Twelve 12" by 12" towels were stained with three teaspoons of Heinz Ketchup to form a stain with a radius od 2.5". Three towels were washed using the directed amount of Tide, three using Gain, three using Green Works and the last three using Seventh Generation. The method was repeated with the Tropicana Orange Juice, coffee and mud. Results Eco-friendly detergents are as effective as if not better than sunthetic detergents. All detergents were thorough in cleaning the towels stained with ketchup and orange juice. However, none of the detergents were able to remove the coffee stain. The towels cleaned by Tide, Gain and Seventh Generation eliminated the coffee stain. On the other hand, Green Works did not remove the mud stain. Conclusions/Discussion At only $0.17 per load, Seventh Generation is a better alternative to Tide which costs $0.23. Seventh Generation is the bets option as it is both eco-friendly and cost-effective.
Summary statement
Are eco-friendly detergents as successful as or better than synthetic detergents?
Help received
Mother helped with board; Father helped with experiment.
Competition history
- CSEF 2012
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2014
Can Green Clean? A Comparison of Name Brand and Environmentally Safe Detergents
CSEF · 2011
War of the Detergents: Green vs. Synthetic: Which Is Better, Green or Synthetic Laundry Detergent?
CSEF · 2009
Are Eco-Friendly Laundry Detergents Really Eco-Friendly?
CSEF · 2009
Is It Easy Being "Green"? Comparing "Green" and Conventional Cleaners on Environmental Impact, Quality, and Cost
CSEF · 2016
Are Green Detergents Biodegradable and Less Toxic?
CSEF · 2014
Going Green While You Clean
ISEF · 2016
Washing Away Vital Elements of Our Environment: A Bio-Assay Investigation with Daphnia, Comparing the Effect of Water Quality and Stream Pollution using "Green Detergent" vs. "Conventional Detergent"
CSEF · 2012
What Laundry Detergent Is Best for the Environment?
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects