Decision Making in the Face of Risk
CSEF · 2009 Behavioral & Social Sciences Second Award
Overview
Objectives/Goals My objectives were to determine (A) how people make decisions when faced with uncertainty and (B) how the framing of a question influences their choices. I expected that teenagers would be more likely than adults to be affected by framing, and that adults, particularly, women, would be more risk averse than teenagers. Methods/Materials Questionnaires were designed to test (i) the effect of framing on people's choices and (ii) risk aversion in two different situations. Two types of questionnaires were distributed to randomly selected teens and adults. Completed questionnaires were sorted by type, age, and gender. For each group, parameters of interest were estimated using 95% confidence intervals, and the differences between different pairs of populations were examined using 95% confidence intervals. This project involved learning methods of statistical inference and mastering Microsoft Office 2007 Excel. Results The study showed that framing has a bigger effect on teenagers than on adults: teenagers reacted strongly to the difference in the framing of the same question on questionnaires A and B, while for adults the observed difference was not significant. Contrary to my hypotheses, teenagers tend to be more risk averse than adults and the difference in proportions of risk averse male and female subjects was not significant. Conclusions/Discussion The study shows that teens are strongly influenced by the framing of a question. The study also shows that when faced with an uncertain situation involving financial gains and losses, teens tend to be more risk averse in their choices than adults. This study does not support the hypothesis that female and male subjects have different attitudes towards risk aversion. This is particularly interesting because intuitively one might expect the opposite. Because risk aversion and responses to wording are important in many areas of life such as education, psychology, economics, etc., these findings are important and should be investigated further.
Summary statement
Compare (i) the effect of framing and (ii) risk aversion in two different situations on teens and adults.
Help received
Dr. Holmes (UCSB) gave me her textbook and guidance on what to learn.
Awards (1)
Competition history
- CSEF 2009
Resources
Related projects
CSEF · 2009
Prospect Theory: Assessing Financial Risk Taking Patterns in Children
CSEF · 2015
Flip or Treat: The Impact of Language on Risk Taking Behavior
ISEF · 2019
Trends and Factors for Risky Behavior among Adolescents
CSEF · 2012
Does "Gender Affects Frustration" Change During Teen Growth?
CSEF · 2004
Tendencies of the Human Mind: The Human Psyche
CSEF · 2014
Post High School Exposure and Its Effect on Post High School Decisions
CSEF · 2016
The Effect of Perceived Risk on the Video Game Performance of Middle School Players
CSEF · 2015
The Effect of Stress on Impulsivity Levels in Adolescents
Closest projects by meaning, across every fair and year in the corpus.
Browse more like this
Source: California Science & Engineering Fair public projects